18 December 2025
AI and the March of Nines
In the Dwarkesh Patel podcast, Andrej Karpathy says that AI development is a "march of nines".
If it takes 1 year to get to 90%, it will take 1 year to get to 99% and another full year to get to 99.9%.
I had not heard of this, but it's a useful concept in many contexts — even a simple programming task.
Developing Pwika (a SVG-based website builder) went like this.
I'd have mostly finished a project, but it was incredibly hard to get through the last bit, and it always mystified me why that was so.
When begining a project, it might be helpful to declare explicitly how many nines will be targeted, eg:
- if it's a 90% project, it'll take a year
- if it's a 99% project, it'll take two years
- …
This might be a useful way to understand how fast AI will transform our society.
My impression is that we're at about 60% — if I ask ChatGPT to help me with something, it frequently fails.
So we're still not even at 90%. Perhaps it will take five more years to get to 90% — so let's say 15 years for 90%
Then we can expect another 15 years to go from 90% to 99%. A very slow takeoff.
Think about self-driving cars — I was driving near my house the other day, and there was construction.
I arrived at a T intersection:
- there was a cement truck parked to the left and another vehicle parked to the right, blocking my view of the perpendicular street I was pulling into
- there was blinding horizontal light from the sunrise
- there was a dark-skinned black man in the sunlight wearing complex clothing
- he was holding a panel that was green on one side and red on the other
- he was indicating, in very haphazard way, when it was safe for me to pull into the other street
- we made eye contact and he made a subtle gesture indicating that I should pull out
Such a situation requires understanding what you're seeing — I have to imagine that a car capable of automatically navigating it lies far in the future.